How To Negotiate With Lien Holders On Underwater Properties

A creative investor in my network bought a property that had $450,000 in liens and judgments recorded against it. The building was worth about $200,000 as is. She paid $500 for it.

Most people hear those numbers and assume there is a catch. There is no catch. There is a method, and very few investors use it, because it requires something most people skip. You have to understand every party with a claim on the property, not just the owner.

Underwater does not mean dead

When a property owes more than it is worth, most investors walk away. The math looks impossible. Nobody pays off $450,000 in debt to own a $200,000 building.

But that assumes every creditor on title is going to collect every dollar. In real life, they rarely do. Some creditors are aggressive. Some are passive. Some have forgotten they are even there. And some made their money a different way and have no intention of ever taking the property.

A property that is underwater on paper can be a very good deal in practice once you know which of those creditors you are actually dealing with.

Build a profile on everyone on title

When this investor gets into a deal with title problems, the first thing she does is identify every party involved. The owner, every lien holder, every judgment creditor, anyone who has recorded an interest.

Then she sorts them. Who is active and who is dormant. Who is strong and who is weak. Who is protecting their position and who has quietly stopped.

On this property, the owner was a single member LLC that had closed its doors. The owner had been through bankruptcy and was renting a small place in another state. He was not going to fight anybody. When she reached him, he was willing to sign whatever was needed.

The creditors were a different story, and that is where the real opportunity was.

The question that changed the deal

One of the recorded items on title was a notice that the city was planning to vote on condemning the building. Every lien holder would have been notified. If the building came down, their collateral would turn into a vacant lot worth a lot less.

So why was nobody doing anything about it?

That question led her to the tax lien holder. They had paid the property taxes for years. Their lien had matured to the point where they could foreclose. They never did.

She went into the public records and looked at their history. They had never foreclosed on a single property. Not one. They were not in the real estate business. They were in the interest business.

That told her exactly how to approach them. A creditor who has no intention of ever taking a property is a creditor who will consider a discount to get out. She negotiated with them, bought their position at a discount, and took control of the priority spot on title.

From there, the other liens and judgments were negotiated or cleared. Today she has about $50,000 into a property worth more than $200,000.

One deal, then a niche

Here is the part most people miss.

Once she knew this particular lien holder never forecloses, she pulled a list of every property they currently hold a lien on. She is now going through that list looking for the ones that are past maturity and being left alone. A creditor walking away from their position, on a property where the owner has also walked away, is a deal waiting for someone curious enough to find it.

She did not buy a list. She built one, from one irregular thing she noticed and refused to ignore.

What this means for you

You do not need to start with a $450,000 title mess to use this thinking. The principle works at any size.

Discounts do not only come from owners. They come from anyone on title who has stopped protecting their interest. Before you make an offer on a property with liens, find out who holds them, what their history looks like, and whether they behave like someone who wants the property or someone who wants out.

A few things to keep in mind. Every state handles liens, redemption periods, and foreclosure differently, and some rights expire if the holder does not act in time. Title work at this level is detailed, and the details decide whether you end up with clean ownership. Work with a title professional and an attorney who handle these situations regularly, and get your structure reviewed before you commit money.

But do not let the paperwork scare you off the idea. The investors who find the deals nobody else sees are usually not smarter. They are more curious. They see something unusual, they ask why, and they keep asking until they understand it.

That curiosity is worth more than any list you can buy.


Kito J. Johnson is the founder of The HEIRS™ Movement (www.theheirsfamily.com), a community of people growing together through faith, real estate, entrepreneurship, and generational wealth building. He is the best-selling author of Real Estate Wealth: Remove The Guesswork From Investing And Create A Six-Figure Strategy and travels nationwide empowering audiences through education in real estate investing, financial literacy, and ownership. Kito is widely recognized for blending kingdom principles with practical strategies that help individuals and families build wealth, stewardship, and lasting legacy through real estate and entrepreneurship. Learn more at www.kitojjohnson.com

Scroll to Top